Advertising disclosure: NonSportCardIndex is a participant in the eBay Partner Network. Links to eBay on this site are advertising, and as an eBay Partner Network affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.
20,597 live listings tracked10,121 card classes11,384 confirmed salesupdated 24 min ago
1966 Batman

1966 OPC Batman Black Bat #35 Cat Woman Defeated

1966 OPC Batman Black Bat #35 Cat Woman Defeated
Buy it now on eBay $21.23 ›cheapest of 3 live listings on eBay
3live listings
5confirmed sales
5grades tracked

Every grade of this card

Raw and graded copies tracked side by side. Prices are asking prices and current bids; comps are confirmed sales.
GradeLiveAsking rangeLast confirmed saleEst. grade (ours)
Raw3$21.23 – $38.93$32.49 2026-10-255.0
TAG ?0———
PSA 3.50—$59.00 2026-10-28—
PSA 40—$66.00 2026-10-19—
KSA 70———

Confirmed sales — all grades

DateGradePriceConfidence
2026-10-28PSA 3.5$59.00HIGH
2026-10-25Raw$32.49HIGH
2026-10-19PSA 4$66.00HIGH
2026-10-13Raw$10.15HIGH
2026-10-09Raw$3.86HIGH

Index grading notes

Estimated grades are this site’s opinion, derived from the seller’s photo and expressed on the PSA scale. Not affiliated with or endorsed by PSA; not a guarantee of any grading outcome.
1966 O-PEE-CHEE BATMAN #35 " CAT WOMAN DEFEATED"
Estimated grade: 6 (5–7) · MEDIUM confidence · asking $38.93

Centering estimate: left border appears slightly narrower than right (~55L/45R), top border slightly narrower than bottom (~55T/45T) — centering is acceptable and does not cap the grade. The yellow field and illustration appear clean with no obvious print snow or heavy toning visible. Corners: the top-right and bottom-right corners show what appears to be very light wear or minor blunting at close inspection, while the left corners look slightly crisper; no sharp razor corners but no significant rounding either — consistent with EX-MT to NM range. Surface gloss appears present with no visible creases or staining. Edge cuts look typical of OPC/vintage rough-cut stock and are not penalized. The main limiting factors are the modest corner wear on 2 corners and the inability to inspect the back or get tight corner closeups, which widens the range; a grade of PSA 6 EX-MT is the most likely outcome, with a realistic ceiling of 7 NM if corners are cleaner than they appear.

1966 O-Pee-Chee Batman Black Bat Batman Catwoman Cat Woman D
Estimated grade: 3 (2–4) · MEDIUM confidence · asking $22.68

Centering estimate: left border ~15%, right border ~20%, top border ~12%, bottom border ~25% — roughly 57/43 L/R but noticeably tight on top vs bottom, approximately 65/35 T/B, so centering is off but not catastrophic. Corners show visible rounding on all four, most pronounced at the top-left and bottom-left, consistent with a VG to VG-EX range. Surface shows significant wear including multiple scratches, scuffs, and what appear to be handling creases across the face — particularly visible in the lower-left quadrant and upper-right area — which push this firmly into VG (3) territory. Gloss is substantially diminished; the yellow background shows toning and surface disturbance consistent with age and handling. A grade of 3 is most likely, with a 4 possible if the surface flaws are lighter than they appear under this lighting and the apparent creases are only scuffs, but a 2 is plausible if any of those marks are true paper-fold creases.

1966 Topps Batman Black Bat Set Card #35 Catwoman Defeated O
Estimated grade: 6 (5–7) · MEDIUM confidence · asking $21.23

Centering estimate: left border appears slightly narrower than right (~55/45 L/R), top border slightly wider than bottom (~55/45 T/B) — centering is acceptable for a PSA 6-7 range. Corners show light-to-moderate rounding on all four, most evident at the lower-left and upper-left; no sharp points visible but no severe blunting either, consistent with EX-MT to NM range. Edges appear reasonably clean with the slightly rough cut typical of OPC stock — not penalized per vintage norms. Surface shows good retained gloss with no visible creases, staining, or print defects beyond minor print texture; the yellow background is vivid with no significant toning. The back cannot be assessed, and OPC versus Topps identity cannot be confirmed from the front; collector should verify back for bilingual text.