Advertising disclosure: NonSportCardIndex is a participant in the eBay Partner Network. Links to eBay on this site are advertising, and as an eBay Partner Network affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.
20,597 live listings tracked10,121 card classes11,384 confirmed salesupdated 24 min ago
1940 Superman

1940 Gum Inc Superman #16 Mountain Tragedy

1940 Gum Inc Superman #16 Mountain Tragedy
Buy it now on eBay $389.99 ›cheapest that names the set, of 6 live listings on eBay
6live listings
1confirmed sales
12grades tracked

Every grade of this card

Raw and graded copies tracked side by side. Prices are asking prices and current bids; comps are confirmed sales.
GradeLiveAsking rangeLast confirmed saleEst. grade (ours)
Raw1$389.99—3.0
TAG ?0———
PSA 11$327.77——
PSA 1.53$2,500.00 – $2,500.00——
PSA 21$450.00——
PSA 2.50———
SGC 30———
PSA 30———
SGC 40———
PSA 50———
CGC 50—$460.00 2026-11-02—
PSA 60———

Confirmed sales — all grades

DateGradePriceConfidence
2026-11-02CGC 5$460.00HIGH

Index grading notes

Estimated grades are this site’s opinion, derived from the seller’s photo and expressed on the PSA scale. Not affiliated with or endorsed by PSA; not a guarantee of any grading outcome.
1940 R145 Superman Gum Inc. #16 Mountain Tragedy
Estimated grade: 3 (2–4) · MEDIUM confidence · asking $389.99

Centering: left/right borders appear roughly 60/40 favoring left, top/bottom approximately 55/45 — centering is acceptable for a VG-range card. Upper-left corner shows visible paper loss or wear consistent with handling damage, and the upper-right corner also appears soft/rounded; the lower corners look slightly better but still show rounding. The card surface exhibits significant toning and age browning throughout, consistent with an 80-year-old gum card stored without protection. No obvious hard creases are visible from this angle, but the overall surface wear, corner condition, and paper stress at the upper-left push this well below EX territory. A grade of PSA 3 (VG) seems most likely; the upper-left corner damage could cap it at PSA 2 if paper loss is confirmed on inspection.