Advertising disclosure: NonSportCardIndex is a participant in the eBay Partner Network. Links to eBay on this site are advertising, and as an eBay Partner Network affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Nonsport Card IndexNSCI-0020567 · GRADED OPINIONS ON EVERY RAW CARD
20,567 live listings tracked10,121 card classes11,414 confirmed salesupdated 0 min ago
1940 Gum Inc Superman #44 Disaster At The Circus

1940 Gum Inc Superman #44 Disaster At The Circus — Raw

1940 Gum Inc Superman #44 Disaster At The Circus — Raw
Buy it now on eBay $231.10 ›cheapest of 1 live listing on eBay
1live listings
1confirmed sales

This card in every grade

What the same card is asking in the other holders this index tracks.
HolderListedCheapestDearest
Raw1$231.10—
TAG ?1$250.00—
PSA 1———
PSA 23$3,000.00$3,000.00
SGC 2———
PSA 2.5———
PSA 3 (MK)———
PSA 3———
SGC 3———
PSA 41$1,150.00—
SGC 4———
SGC 4.5———
PSA 5 (MK)———
PSA 51$5,000.00—
PSA 7———

Asking range

Half of the 3 Buy It Now listings tracked are asking between $98 and $245, median $100.
$80$175$269Aug 6 2026 - median $112, middle half $104 to $251, 3 listingsAug 13 2026 - median $112, middle half $104 to $251, 3 listingsAug 20 2026 - median $100, middle half $98 to $245, 3 listingsSold Sep 15 - $158Aug 6Aug 20
Shaded band is the middle half of live Buy It Now asking prices, weekly intervals; the line is the median. Auctions are excluded - a climbing bid is not an asking price. The scale follows the asking prices, so a sale well outside them is pinned to the edge rather than flattening the band.middle halfconfirmed salebest offer, at its cap

Confirmed sales

DatePriceBasisListing
2026-09-15$157.50HIGH · final bid1940 Gum Inc. Superman #44 Disaster At The Circus
1 listed · 1 seller · 1 confirmed sale30-day window

Live listings

Asking prices and current bids — not values. Est. grade is our opinion from the seller’s photo, on the PSA scale — see notes below.
PriceTypeEst. grade (ours)Est. ROI after gradingListing (opens eBay)
1940 Superman Gum R145 Superman Disaster at the Circus #44 R$231.10Buy It Now2 (2–3)+$2,138.90+819% · ask $2,400.001940 Superman Gum R145 Superman Disaster at the Circus #44 READ 04le on eBay

Index grading notes

Estimated grades are this site’s opinion, derived from the seller’s photo and expressed on the PSA scale. Not affiliated with or endorsed by PSA; not a guarantee of any grading outcome.
1940 Superman Gum R145 Superman Disaster at the Circus #44 R
Estimated grade: 2 (2–3) · MEDIUM confidence · asking $231.10

Centering estimate: left border appears roughly equal to right (~50/50 L/R), top and bottom borders appear moderately balanced (~55/45 T/B) — centering is not a primary concern here. The seller explicitly notes creases, and the photo confirms at least two visible diagonal creases running across the card face — one prominent crease crossing the upper-left quadrant and another through the lower portion — which is consistent with a PSA 2 GOOD or at best PSA 3 VG. Corner condition is difficult to assess precisely from this single photo but corners appear rounded with visible wear. Surface shows gloss loss and the creases are structurally significant, not merely light surface wrinkles. The card appears intact with no tears or paper loss visible, keeping it out of PR-FR territory, but the multiple creases cap this firmly at the 2–3 range.